Who Keyed Vincent's Car? - Pulp Fiction The Movie Fan Site

Note: You must be registered and logged in to post a comment

Re:
by Pulp on 2008-06-03 21:39:20

The conventional wisdom is that Butch keyed Vincent's car. He did have a motive (Vincent called him Punchy and Palooka in the bar) and it seems to be fairly consistent with his character.

Re:
by nikko on 2008-06-16 03:29:57

yep - looks like Butch did it. Apparently, in the script it says that Vincent pulled into the car park and parked right next to Butch's car despite the fact that the car park was almost empty. Butch left before Vincent and he was incensed at what Vincent had said to him.

Re: agree...
by brill301 on 2008-06-17 22:57:55

I agree, it must of been butch, or maybe it was nobody.(characters in the movie)

Re:
by caleywagles on 2008-07-19 22:36:23

I never really thought that it was Butch but it would kind of make since because of the way they act towards each other. I Don't think that Butch would go out like such a bitch though. He is a boxer. He would probably kick Vincents ass before he would do that.

Re:
by ShngrlLVSPlpfctn on 2008-07-20 21:57:06

Did you even see the movie? What are you talking about? If you really knew the movie, you'd know that Butch isn't gonna kick Vincent's ass because Vincent is prepared to blow Butch into pieces...but fortunately for Butch he caught Vincent off guard and blew him away first! Really though, did you see the movie?

Re:
by Waroflight on 2008-08-11 14:55:18

Actually, the reason that Butch does not confront Vincent after their first interaction is because we hear Marcellus warmly and enthusiastically greet Vincent in the background. As a result, Butch gets his revenge for Vincent's comments by keying his car.

Re:
by ammo504 on 2008-08-14 07:57:42

damn that makes so much fucking sense, i was having a hard time saying that Butch did it just because he and Vincent dont like each other but now i think that is what really happend, a better question now would be why Vincent dislikes Butch, is it becuase Butch is considering throwing the fight?

Re: Who Keyed Vincent's Car?
by CBR44 on 2008-08-15 10:01:12

I thought it was random at first until I had watched it for about the 10th time and I thought that Butch had to be the obvious choice. His discovery of the keying immediately followed Vincent and Butch's run-in at the club....Butch had incentive to disrespect Vincent as Vincent disrespected him.

Re: Who Keyed Vincent's Car?
by kingjef1 on 2008-08-24 12:33:58

In an interview with Quentin Tarantino, he told us that it was Butch he keyed his car, but he did it not because he didn't like Vincent, but because he has the ability to key cars I guess. So it was Butch.

Re:
by winstonthewolf on 2008-09-03 13:11:56

No I dont think butch keyed it because after the diner scene they went straight to give marcellus wallace the case but they didnt have a car with them, remember the wolf said " i see your future its a cab ride" so they take a cab to brekfast and take another to meet marcellus and even if vince did take a cab to his house and then get his own car which he didnt do, he would have not showed up in jimmie's dorky clothes he would have changed (and probley let jules borrow clothes too.) but no they came straight from the diner, so vinces car could not have been in the parking lot for butch key after butch in vince have their face off!

Re:
by Pulp on 2008-09-03 14:35:10

That last comment was Sherlock Holmes-ian... a brilliant deduction. Unless anyone can realistically dispute this I think winstonthewolf deserves the Nerdoh t-shirt!

Re:
by winstonthewolf on 2008-09-06 14:11:31

so do i get my shirt ??

Re:
by wwsljd on 2008-09-10 21:34:05

Actually, I think that, since he went with his boy (Jules) they met up at Marsellus's bar and took Jules' car. So, Vincent's car would still be at the bar. After all, they did have to meet with Marsellus to get the info about the dudes in the apartment at some point. Butch does make the most sense, but the challenge is for the most interesting possibility, so I think it would be funny if it was Paul who keyed the car, because he was mad that he was the only character who didn't get enough screen time (except for Jules, he could never get enough screen time) and SLJ got his role.

Re: winstonthewolf's debunked
by CBR44 on 2008-09-11 11:36:24

That was a nice try, but wwsljd makes the ultimate point that Vince's car never left the parking lot at the club.....who's car they used is beyond me, it was ultimately destroyed with no dispute. If it was Jules' car, he could easily afford another, but he would'nt have needed one to "walk the earth" would he?

Contest Winner
by Pulp on 2008-09-12 07:38:54

The contest is over. We sent the t-shirt to Winstonthewolf. Even if were not the correct answer (is there a correct answer?) it was definitely the most surprising / interesting answer to me. It's amazing how the Pulp Fiction timeline fucks with your head.

Note: You must be registered and logged in to post a comment


Note: This is a fan site. We have nothing to do whatsoever with Mr. Tarantino besides the fact we love him and his fabulous movies.

There are 15 user comments